Divorcing Couple

What Happens When a Divorcing Couple Owns Property in Different States?

Even though a divorcing couple may own a family home in one state and a rental house in another, one divorce court may be able to address both. What the court can do will depend on its authority over the spouses, the laws governing their property rights and the manner in which ownership is transferred.

When one spouse receives a property, the division can account for its value through cash or other assets awarded to the other spouse. Selling it and dividing the proceeds is another option. An award may still leave transfer work to complete where the land is located.

Deciding Which Court Has Authority

While a court in one state may be able to grant a divorce when its filing requirements are met, it may lack authority to impose financial obligations on the other spouse or determine that spouse’s property rights. For a court to order one spouse to transfer property to the other, it generally needs personal jurisdiction, meaning legal authority over the spouse who must act.

Even though a spouse is residing in another state, that spouse may still come under the court’s authority in the state in which the divorce was filed. This can be accomplished through consent of the parties, or through sufficient legal connections of the other spouse to that state. Service of divorce papers by mail in another state does not, by itself, establish personal jurisdiction. An experienced divorce lawyer like those at Davis & Associates can assess these issues.

A court in one state generally cannot transfer title to real property located in another state by its decree alone. In such a case, a court with personal jurisdiction over the owner can order that spouse to sign the appropriate documents to transfer title. The order acts on the owner, and any deed must meet the legal requirements of the state where the land is located.

If the owner refuses to sign, the spouse awarded the property may need to return to the divorce court to enforce the order. Proceedings in the state where the land is located may also be needed to complete the transfer. The court’s decision about the spouses’ rights and the paperwork that transfers ownership are separate parts of the process.

Determining What Is Available to Divide

The location of the property is only part of the story. The court will also need to know when the property was acquired, where the parties resided at the time the property was acquired, and with what funds the property was acquired.

All states have laws that govern the classification and division of assets in a divorce. For example, in California community property is generally divided equally between spouses. In Florida, however, the court begins with an equal distribution of the parties’ marital assets but can arrive at an unequal distribution based on a number of relevant factors.

Separate property can include property owned prior to the marriage, as well as property acquired during the marriage through individual gift or inheritance. However, even separate property can be affected in a division of property in a divorce action, as for example in Washington, where both community property and separate property are subject to a just and equitable division in a divorce action.

Marital funds used to pay down the mortgage on a separately owned property may create a marital claim under the applicable state law. Records of the original purchase, loan payments and improvements can help establish the interests involved. They do not necessarily put the whole property in one category.

California provides one example of how a move can affect classification. Property acquired during marriage while a spouse was legally at home in another state can qualify as quasi-community property. The test is whether it would have been community property had the acquiring spouse’s legal home been California at the time. That classification question needs its own legal analysis. Neither the property’s address nor the divorce filing location necessarily tells the spouses which law governs their rights.

Making the Division Work in Practice

First, determine what property exists and what debts are outstanding. This can include property and debts located in another state. Collect all relevant deeds, mortgage statements, purchase agreements and other relevant agreements between the spouses.

It is also important to determine the value of the property and any associated debt. The market value of a house can be quite different from the amount of equity that is available after any secured debt is paid off. In some cases, an appraisal may be required to determine the value of a property. A division based on an outdated estimate or an overlooked mortgage can give the spouses a misleading view of what each would receive.

One spouse can receive the house and the other receive cash or other property in exchange. The terms of the settlement should be clearly set out in written documents, including who will sign the deed, when the transfer or payment is due and who handles recording. The documents should also state what happens if a sale falls through or the spouse keeping the property is unable to obtain financing.

The deed and the mortgage serve different purposes. The deed concerns ownership, while the loan identifies who has promised to repay the lender. A spouse’s removal from the deed does not, by itself, release that spouse from a joint mortgage. The lender’s requirements and the loan terms still apply after a divorce award. Removing the borrower may require a lender’s release or refinancing that excludes that borrower.

The arrangements should also allocate any mortgage payments, taxes, insurance and maintenance costs that fall due before the transfer or sale is complete. Each spouse needs to know which bills to pay, and for how long, while the award is being carried out.